Smart Doorbell Privacy Laws, How to Avoid Breaking The Law

🔊 Listen to Post

Understanding the Legal Risks of Home Surveillance

Smart doorbells such as Ring, Nest, and Eufy have grown in popularity due to their convenience and added security. However, many homeowners and tenants don’t realise that installing these devices without following proper privacy laws can land them in legal hot water. Surveillance technology can be both a deterrent to crime and a potential invasion of privacy if not used correctly.

Privacy Laws and Smart Doorbells

In the UK, the use of smart doorbells and CCTV is regulated under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the UK GDPR when the cameras capture footage beyond your private property (e.g., public pavements, shared hallways, neighbours’ driveways).

If your camera records areas outside your boundary, you are considered a data controller under UK GDPR.

This means you must:

• Inform people they are being recorded (clear signage is required)
• Keep footage secure and only for as long as necessary
• Avoid recording private spaces unnecessarily
• Provide access to footage if requested by individuals whose images are captured

Failure to comply can result in complaints to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) and possible enforcement action.

Case Study: The Photographer and the Hidden CCTV

Several years ago, I shared an office with a photographer who had CCTV cameras installed in the studio. However, there were no signs to warn visitors or staff that a recording was taking place. This made me extremely uncomfortable.

Whenever clients visited, I made a point of discreetly letting them know about the cameras, as I believed they had the right to be informed. Over time, tensions rose between the photographer and me. The situation escalated into a heated argument, and the photographer later ceased trading. To protect my safety and privacy after our professional split, I also took the added measure of blocking both him and his wife on all social media platforms. This experience taught me first-hand the importance of transparency and legal compliance when using surveillance equipment.

Surveillance Cameras and Disabled People

For disabled individuals, surveillance cameras can be a vital tool for safety, independence, and well-being. They can also help carers, family members, and emergency responders act quickly in critical situations.

Reasons a camera may be installed for a disabled person include:

• Monitoring for falls or accidents when the individual lives alone
• Checking on medical equipment such as ventilators or oxygen supply
• Providing reassurance to family members and carers
• Monitoring entrances to prevent doorstep scams or harassment
• Security against break-ins when mobility limitations make evacuation difficult
• Recording incidents for evidence in cases of abuse or neglect
• Facilitating remote care where carers can check in without disturbing rest or routine

Where cameras should not be installed:

• Bathrooms or toilets, recording in these areas is almost always illegal unless there is an exceptional, legally justified reason (e.g., medical care with explicit consent)
• Bedrooms, unless absolutely necessary for medical monitoring, and with informed consent
• Shared areas without consent, such as communal hallways or shared gardens in flats
• Neighbouring private property, recording other people’s homes, gardens, or inside their windows, is a breach of privacy

The key principle is necessity and proportionality; only record what is essential for safety and care, and always obtain consent where possible.

Best Practices for Residents with Smart Doorbells

If you have or are considering installing a smart doorbell, here’s how to stay within the law:

1. Put Up Clear Signage
   Display a visible sign stating that CCTV or video recording is in operation.
2. Adjust Camera Angles
   Avoid pointing cameras directly into neighbours’ windows, gardens, or private spaces.
3. Limit Audio Recording
   Many smart doorbells capture sound as well as video, which can be more intrusive. Disable audio recording if possible.
4. Secure Your Data
   Use strong passwords, two-factor authentication, and encrypted storage for footage.
5. Respond to Subject Access Requests
   If someone requests footage of themselves, you must provide it within the legal timeframe.
6. Regularly Review Footage Policies
   Delete unnecessary footage and keep records only for a reasonable period (usually 30 days unless needed for legal reasons).

Potential Legal Consequences

• ICO Complaints – Neighbours or visitors can file complaints if they believe their privacy rights have been infringed.
• Civil Claims – In extreme cases, individuals can sue for breach of privacy.
• Reputational Damage – Even if no legal action is taken, disputes over surveillance can damage relationships and trust.

Final Thoughts

Smart doorbells can be valuable tools for home security, but misuse can lead to costly disputes and potential legal penalties. The key is transparency—always inform people when they’re being recorded and follow data protection principles.

My own experience sharing an office with hidden CCTV cameras reinforced how quickly trust can break down when privacy is not respected. A simple sign and a conversation could have avoided conflict.