Back To Work Solutions To Avoid DWP Sanctions
The issue of unemployment continues to be a complex challenge, exacerbated by the current cost of living crisis and widespread cuts to business resources and funding. According to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), approximately 9 million people in the UK are unemployed, a figure that highlights the pressing need for effective solutions to bring people back into the workforce. However, businesses are finding it increasingly difficult to hire, especially when faced with rising operational costs and limited government support. As employers tighten their belts, vulnerable groups—especially those with disabilities or long-term health conditions—are often overlooked in hiring decisions.
The Business Perspective: A Tough Climate for Hiring
For many businesses, the reality of high inflation, energy costs, and reduced government support makes hiring new employees a financial strain. Companies have to make tough decisions, often choosing to forgo hiring altogether or, in some cases, opting not to hire individuals who may require additional accommodations. Adapting workplaces for accessibility, providing disability-friendly resources, and addressing health and safety risks involve significant investments—investments many small and medium-sized enterprises simply cannot afford.
The Equality Act 2010 requires businesses to make “reasonable adjustments” for employees with disabilities. However, without adequate funding or support from the government, many businesses may find this financially unfeasible. The result is indirect discrimination: qualified candidates, especially those with disabilities, are left on the sidelines.
Coercion into Unsuitable Jobs
Another pressing issue is the coercion of people with long-term unemployment or on sick leave into unsuitable jobs. This often involves individuals being forced into roles they may not be physically or mentally able to perform, a practice that raises significant human rights concerns. For instance, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights asserts that everyone has the right to “work, to free choice of employment, [and] to just and favorable conditions of work.” Forcing someone into a job that worsens their health or forces them into a work environment that doesn’t accommodate their needs could potentially breach this principle.
Recent government crackdowns on long-term unemployment aim to reduce unemployment figures by pressuring individuals into jobs they may dislike or be unsuitable for. Such pressure often comes with the threat of sanctions—if a person refuses a job offer, their benefits may be reduced or cut altogether. This raises an important legal question: Is it legal to force someone into unsuitable employment, particularly when it goes against their health or personal well-being? While the government’s approach may reduce unemployment figures on paper, it doesn’t provide a sustainable or humane solution for individuals who need long-term support.
The Impact on Disabled Individuals
The discrimination disabled individuals face in the workforce further compounds the problem. Of the 9 million unemployed, an estimated 2.5 million people are classified as long-term sick or disabled, representing a substantial portion of those out of work. According to the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), 14.6 million people in the UK live with a disability, many of whom are eager to work but encounter significant barriers in the hiring process.
A key issue is the reluctance of employers to take on individuals who may present a health and safety risk or require expensive adaptations. This reluctance not only violates disability rights but also perpetuates a cycle of poverty and dependence on welfare for many disabled individuals.
Proposed Solutions
- Upskilling and Reskilling Programs: One possible solution to unemployment is to encourage individuals to learn a new skill or trade. By providing incentives for education and training, the government could help people transition into industries where there is greater demand, all while keeping them on benefits during their studies. This approach would ensure that people are working toward a job that aligns with their skills and passions, rather than being coerced into unsuitable roles. Additionally, skilled individuals are more likely to start their own businesses, reducing their dependency on the DWP and avoiding sanctions.
- Support for Entrepreneurs: Encouraging entrepreneurship could be another way to tackle unemployment. Starting a small business gives individuals a sense of purpose and control over their work environment, allowing them to create inclusive and accessible workplaces. The government should provide grants and low-interest loans to individuals interested in starting their own business, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds, ensuring they have the resources to succeed.
- Enhanced Workplace Accessibility Funding: The government must provide increased financial support to businesses to improve workplace accessibility. This could include grants for making reasonable adjustments, such as installing ramps, modifying workspaces, and ensuring that health and safety standards are met for individuals with disabilities. By doing so, businesses would be more willing to hire individuals with health conditions, knowing that they have the financial support to meet their obligations.
- Incentivizing Employers to Hire: Tax breaks or financial incentives for businesses that employ people with long-term unemployment or disabilities could encourage employers to take on staff they might otherwise avoid. These incentives would offset the cost of any necessary workplace adaptations and health and safety measures, making it easier for employers to comply with equality laws while contributing to a more diverse workforce.
Legal and Ethical Considerations
Finally, it is important to address the legal implications of coercing individuals into unsuitable jobs. Sanctioning people for refusing work that does not align with their abilities or well-being could be seen as discriminatory and a violation of human rights. According to the Universal Credit statistics, over 2.6 million people are currently claiming unemployment-related benefits, many of whom are at risk of sanctions if they do not comply with government requirements to accept jobs. This practice raises serious ethical concerns about the treatment of the unemployed, particularly the long-term sick and disabled.
Conclusion
The UK’s unemployment crisis, especially among the long-term sick and disabled, cannot be solved through coercion or by pressuring individuals into unsuitable jobs. Instead, the government must focus on solutions that respect human rights, promote inclusion, and provide opportunities for personal growth. Upskilling, entrepreneurship, and better financial support for workplace adaptations can create a more sustainable path back to work, benefiting both individuals and the economy as a whole.
Renata, the editor of DisabledEntrepreneur.uk, DisabilityUk.co.uk, and DisabilityUK.org, once worked in a shared studio office space where she struggled daily with her severe OCD. Before she could begin work, she found it overwhelming to disinfect everything, including the desks, chairs, computer keyboard, cameras, lenses, light switches, and printers. Out of fear and shame, she hid her disability from her colleagues. A few incidents stick in her mind when she cleaned the desks with antibacterial wet wipes consequently causing the coating of the ply wood to bubble and crack. On another occasion she wiped a wall and gloss paint started to peel. Handling cash was not a problem back then as she disinfected her hands with hand sanitizer regularly. She was lucky in the sense she did not damage the camera equipment, which would have proven costly, from her excessive disinfecting and ultimately could have got her fired if she was an employee, however she was self employed and simply shared office space and filled in when the photographer was away.
Today, Renata is fully open about her disabilities, using her platforms to educate others, spread awareness, and break down barriers surrounding disability in the workplace. Renata now works remotely, doesn’t handle cash as she had to explain to the window cleaner recently, and, since the COVID lockdowns, has noticed a significant worsening of her OCD. This has led her to socially disconnect from the outside world other than meeting delivery driver, couriers and contractors. She is currently working on her recovery, taking it one small step at a time.
Sources:
- Office for National Statistics (ONS), Labour Market Overview, 2024
- Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), Disability Statistics, 2024
- Universal Declaration of Human Rights
- Keir Starmer warns long-term benefit claimants they should have to look for work (msn.com)
- DWP lists benefit claimants who will get ‘transitional element’ in Universal Credit move (msn.com)