Why Do Insurance Brokers Insist on Phoning You

---

🔊 Listen to Post

---

Why Do Insurance Brokers Insist on Phoning You Instead of Emailing Quotes?

If you’ve ever requested a quote from an insurance broker, you’ve likely experienced the frustration of brokers insisting on calling you rather than emailing the information. This can feel intrusive, especially when you receive unscheduled calls during busy or inconvenient times. Many customers wonder why brokers don’t simply send a quote via email or provide an online questionnaire instead of forcing a phone call. Some brokers even claim that regulatory requirements, such as those from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), mandate these calls. But is that really true?

Common Reasons Brokers Insist on Phoning You

1. Building a Personal Connection: One of the primary reasons brokers prefer phone calls is to establish a personal relationship with the client. A direct conversation allows them to build rapport, understand your needs more deeply, and position themselves as trusted advisors rather than just salespeople.
2. Upselling and Cross-Selling Opportunities: Phone calls give brokers the chance to upsell or cross-sell other products. By having a conversation, they can better gauge your needs and recommend additional coverage or services that you might not have initially considered. This approach is more challenging to achieve through email.
3. Handling Complex Information: Insurance quotes often involve complex terms, conditions, and exclusions that may require further explanation. Brokers may feel that a phone conversation allows them to clarify details and answer any immediate questions, reducing the chance of misunderstandings that could lead to complaints later.
4. Increased Conversion Rates: From a sales perspective, phone calls are more effective than emails in converting leads into customers. A real-time conversation provides brokers with an opportunity to address objections and persuade you to commit on the spot, which is much harder to achieve through written communication.
5. Regulatory Compliance Claims: Some brokers claim that the FCA requires them to discuss quotes over the phone rather than send them via email. This argument, however, seems to be more of a sales tactic than a regulatory mandate. The FCA focuses on ensuring that information is provided clearly, fairly, and not misleadingly but does not specifically dictate that quotes must be given over the phone.

Is It True That the FCA Requires Brokers to Phone You?

The short answer is no. The FCA does not mandate that insurance brokers must provide quotes exclusively over the phone. The FCA’s primary concern is that the information given to customers is clear, fair, and not misleading, regardless of the medium used. While brokers must ensure that customers fully understand the terms of their policies, there is no specific rule that prohibits brokers from sending quotes via email or providing an online questionnaire.

Instead, the insistence on phone calls is more about the brokers’ sales strategy than regulatory requirements. They aim to maximize their chance of making a sale and ensure that all potential objections are handled immediately. If a broker tells you that they are required to call you due to FCA regulations, it’s likely they are either misinformed or using it as a tactic to secure your engagement.

Why an Online Questionnaire Could Be a Better Approach

Given the challenges associated with phone calls, a more customer-friendly approach could involve an online questionnaire that captures all the necessary details in writing. This method allows customers to provide accurate information at their own pace and avoid the pressure of an immediate sales pitch. Additionally, written communication provides a clear record of what has been discussed, reducing the likelihood of misunderstandings.

Your Rights as a Consumer

As a consumer, you have the right to request information in the format that suits you best. If you prefer to receive your quote via email, make this clear to the broker. If they insist on a phone call, you can remind them that there is no regulatory obligation requiring this and that written communication is both preferred and more transparent.

Conclusion

This happened to me this morning and the broker said he needed to call as part of the FCA guidelines. As a law student, I needed to find out if this was true and as a consequence of him lying to me he has lost the sale as I will be emailing him this article. What people need to understand is you have to be transparent and never lie to a potential customer, if you do not wish to be caught out.

If an insurance broker is dishonest from the start they lose trustworthiness and credibility, giving you a reason to doubt the service they are selling.

---